CarMax vs Costco

Side-by-side comparison of AI visibility scores, market position, and capabilities

Costco leads in AI visibility (93 vs 80)
CarMax logo

CarMax

LeaderConsumer Retail

Enterprise

Richmond VA largest US used car retailer (NYSE: KMX) at $26.37B FY2025 revenue; CEO Nash stepping down Dec 2025 with Q3 FY2026 comp sales -8-12% and Edmunds integration competing with Carvana for used vehicle omnichannel retail.

AI VisibilityBeta
Overall Score
A80
Category Rank
#22 of 347
AI Consensus
89%
Trend
stable
Per Platform
ChatGPT
78
Perplexity
81
Gemini
79

About

CarMax, Inc. is a Richmond, Virginia-based used car retailer — publicly traded on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE: KMX) as an S&P 500 component — operating as the largest used vehicle retailer in the United States with 250 stores across 109 television markets, 30,000+ associates, and fiscal year 2025 revenue of $26.37 billion (fiscal year ended February 28, 2025). Founded in 1993 as a Circuit City subsidiary in Richmond, CarMax pioneered no-haggle pricing and quality inspections in the used car market, introducing a consumer-friendly alternative to high-pressure dealership tactics. CarMax acquired Edmunds (consumer automotive research) for $404 million in 2021, enhancing digital capabilities and cross-platform vehicle discovery. In late 2025, CarMax announced significant leadership changes: CEO Bill Nash stepped down effective December 1, 2025 after nearly nine years, with Board member David McCreight named Interim President and CEO and former CEO Tom Folliard appointed Interim Executive Chair. The leadership transition came alongside a preliminary Q3 FY2026 outlook showing comparable store used unit sales declining 8-12% amid a soft used car market.

Full profile
Costco logo

Costco

LeaderConsumer Retail

Warehouse Retail

NASDAQ: COST warehouse club at $249.6B FY2024 revenue with 73.4M cardholders and $50B+ Kirkland Signature; 90%+ renewal rate with $65/$130 membership fee competing with Sam's Club for warehouse retail.

AI VisibilityBeta
Overall Score
A93
Category Rank
#3 of 347
AI Consensus
83%
Trend
stable
Per Platform
ChatGPT
91
Perplexity
88
Gemini
94

About

Costco Wholesale Corporation is an Issaquah, Washington-based membership warehouse club — listed on NASDAQ (NASDAQ: COST) — operating 897 warehouse locations globally (as of mid-2025) across the United States, Canada, United Kingdom, Japan, Korea, Australia, Spain, France, China, and Iceland, providing paid members (73.4 million cardholders representing 136.8 million authorized users as of fiscal year end 2024) with bulk merchandise, groceries, electronics, appliances, tires, optical services, pharmacy, and the Kirkland Signature private label brand at prices consistently below traditional retail channels. Costco generated $249.6 billion in total revenue in fiscal year 2024 (ended September 2024, +5% year-over-year), with membership fee revenue of $4.83 billion providing the financial foundation that enables Costco's famously low product margins.

Full profile

AI Visibility Head-to-Head

80
Overall Score
93
#22
Category Rank
#3
89
AI Consensus
83
stable
Trend
stable
78
ChatGPT
91
81
Perplexity
88
79
Gemini
94
77
Claude
93
81
Grok
95

Key Details

Category
Enterprise
Warehouse Retail
Tier
Leader
Leader
Entity Type
company
company

Capabilities & Ecosystem

Capabilities

Only Costco
Warehouse Retail

Integrations

Only CarMax
Only Costco
CarMax is classified as company. Costco is classified as company.

Track AI Visibility in Real Time

Monitor how your brand performs across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, and Grok daily.