CMS Energy vs FirstEnergy
Side-by-side comparison of AI visibility scores, market position, and capabilities
Jackson MI Michigan regulated utility (NYSE: CMS) ~$8.4B FY2024 revenue; Consumers Energy 6.8M customers, 18 consecutive earnings guidance years, PA 235 clean energy 2040 mandate competing with DTE Energy.
About
CMS Energy Corporation is a Jackson, Michigan-based regulated electric and gas utility holding company — publicly traded on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE: CMS) as an S&P 500 Utilities component — serving approximately 6.8 million electric and 1.8 million natural gas customers throughout Michigan through its principal subsidiary Consumers Energy (Michigan's largest utility, serving 68 of Michigan's 83 counties) through approximately 7,500 employees. In fiscal year 2024, CMS Energy reported revenues of approximately $8.4 billion and adjusted EPS of approximately $3.29, growing within the company's 6-8% annual adjusted EPS guidance range that has made CMS Energy one of the most consistent earnings growth utilities in the US — delivering 18 consecutive years of meeting or exceeding earnings guidance under the management team's "CE Way" lean operational improvement program. CEO Garrick Rochow leads CMS Energy's strategy of executing a $20+ billion capital plan (2024-2028) focused on renewable energy generation (wind and solar replacing coal-fired generation ahead of the Michigan Public Service Commission's clean energy mandate), electric distribution grid hardening (replacing 1,750 miles of distribution lines annually to reduce storm outage frequency and duration), and natural gas infrastructure modernization. Michigan's Governor Whitmer's 100% clean energy by 2040 mandate (PA 235 — enacted 2023) requires Consumers Energy to retire coal plants, add significant renewable energy generation, and build battery storage — translating directly into approved rate base capital investment that earns Consumers Energy's authorized return on equity (approximately 9.9%).
Akron OH Midwest/Mid-Atlantic regulated utility (NYSE: FE) ~$13.5B FY2024 revenue; HB 6 scandal recovery complete, $26B 2024-2028 capex, 6M customers in 6 states, data center NJ growth competing with AEP and Exelon.
About
FirstEnergy Corp. is an Akron, Ohio-based regulated electric utility holding company — publicly traded on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE: FE) as an S&P 500 Utilities component — providing electric transmission and distribution service to approximately 6 million customers across six states (Ohio, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, New Jersey, Maryland, New York) through regulated utility subsidiaries including Ohio Edison, Cleveland Electric Illuminating, Toledo Edison, Pennsylvania Power, The Illuminating Company, Monongahela Power, Potomac Edison, Jersey Central Power & Light, Met-Ed, Penn Power, and West Penn Power through approximately 12,000 employees. FirstEnergy is in the final stages of reputational and operational recovery from a historic corporate governance scandal: in 2020, FirstEnergy admitted to paying $60 million in bribes to Ohio utility regulators and state legislators (including former Ohio House Speaker Larry Householder) to secure passage of HB 6 — a $1.3 billion nuclear plant bailout law that was later repealed — resulting in criminal convictions, executive departures, shareholder class action settlements, and a $230 million DOJ deferred prosecution agreement. In fiscal year 2024, FirstEnergy reported revenues of approximately $13.5 billion, with the company executing CEO Brian Tierney's (joined 2023) strategy of rebuilding regulatory trust, improving operational performance, and executing the $26 billion capital plan (2024-2028) for grid modernization, electric vehicle infrastructure, and smart meter installation across the six-state service territory. FirstEnergy's 2021 divestiture of its competitive power generation business (FirstEnergy Solutions — renamed Evolent Energy Resources, including the Davis-Besse and Perry nuclear plants in Ohio) simplified FirstEnergy to a pure regulated utility — eliminating the commodity generation exposure that had distorted earnings and contributed to the improper HB 6 lobbying motivation.
AI Visibility Head-to-Head
Key Details
Also Compare
Track AI Visibility in Real Time
Monitor how your brand performs across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, and Grok daily.