Care/of vs Ulta Beauty
Side-by-side comparison of AI visibility scores, market position, and capabilities
Personalized vitamin subscription brand acquired by Bayer for $225M in 2020; continues as digital-native supplement label under Bayer Consumer Health.
About
Care/of is a New York-based personalized vitamin and supplement brand founded in 2016 by Craig Elbert and Akash Shah. The company popularized algorithm-driven supplement personalization, asking consumers a series of lifestyle and health questions to recommend a custom daily vitamin pack delivered by subscription. Care/of was acquired by Bayer in November 2020 at a $225 million valuation, giving Bayer a majority ownership stake in the direct-to-consumer brand.\n\nUnder Bayer's Consumer Health division, Care/of has continued to operate with its original DTC model and brand identity while leveraging Bayer's supply chain, clinical validation resources, and marketing infrastructure. The brand extended its product line to include protein powders, collagen supplements, and wellness shots, maintaining its personalization-first positioning in a crowded supplement market.\n\nCare/of targets millennial consumers who value personalized wellness plans and want evidence-cited ingredient explanations. The brand's website provides research citations for every recommended ingredient, a transparency approach that built early credibility and loyalty. As part of Bayer, Care/of benefits from credentialing by association with a global pharmaceutical brand while retaining its digital-native identity.
NASDAQ-listed (ULTA) largest US beauty retailer with 1,400+ stores and 44M loyalty members; prestige-to-mass-plus-salon format competing with Sephora and Target shop-in-shop for total beauty spend.
About
Ulta Beauty is the largest US beauty retailer — operating 1,400+ stores across 50 states that combine prestige, mass-market, and salon product sales with in-store salon and beauty services in a single destination format that no other beauty retailer matches. Listed on NASDAQ (NASDAQ: ULTA), Ulta generated approximately $11.3 billion in net sales in fiscal year 2024 and operates the Ultamate Rewards loyalty program with 44+ million members, which is among the largest loyalty programs in US retail.
AI Visibility Head-to-Head
Key Details
Capabilities & Ecosystem
Capabilities
Integrations
Also Compare
Track AI Visibility in Real Time
Monitor how your brand performs across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, and Grok daily.