Michaels vs Old Navy

Side-by-side comparison of AI visibility scores, market position, and capabilities

Old Navy leads in AI visibility (60 vs 23)

Michaels

UnknownConsumer Retail

General

North America's largest arts and crafts retail chain with 1,250+ stores; Apollo-owned with Jo-Ann bankruptcy creating expansion opportunity competing with Hobby Lobby.

AI VisibilityBeta
Overall Score
D23
Category Rank
#841 of 1167
AI Consensus
60%
Trend
stable
Per Platform
ChatGPT
17
Perplexity
29
Gemini
31

About

Michaels is North America's largest specialty arts and crafts retail chain, operating over 1,250 company-owned stores in the US and Canada offering a vast selection of art supplies, custom picture framing, scrapbooking and paper crafts, yarn and needle arts, seasonal craft supplies, and home décor. Founded in 1973 in Irving, Texas, Michaels went private in a $6.1 billion leveraged buyout led by Apollo Global Management and Blackstone in 2006, then went public again in 2014, and was taken private again in 2021 by Apollo Global Management for approximately $5 billion.\n\nMichaels' product range spans over 45,000 SKUs in major categories: art supplies (paints, canvases, drawing materials), custom framing (in-store custom frame shop), floral (artificial flowers, wreaths), yarn and needle arts (extensive yarn selection, knitting supplies), seasonal (Halloween, Christmas craft supplies), and general crafts. The Michaels brand has added private label brands (Artist's Loft, Recollections for scrapbooking) that generate higher margins than national brands. In-store classes and workshops turn the store into a community space that drives engagement and repeat visits beyond purchases.\n\nIn 2025, Michaels competes with Hobby Lobby, Jo-Ann Fabric and Craft Stores (which filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in 2024, creating market share opportunity), and Michael's own Amazon storefronts for arts and crafts retail. Jo-Ann's bankruptcy and potential store closures represent a significant competitive opportunity for Michaels to gain share in the fabric and needle arts segments. The crafting market benefited from COVID-era growth as homebound consumers took up crafts, and the category has maintained elevated participation. Michaels' 2025 strategy focuses on capturing Jo-Ann customer migration, growing the Michaels Pro segment (artists, educators, craft businesses), expanding digital and e-commerce capabilities, and deepening the community/workshop programming that differentiates physical craft retail.

Full profile

Old Navy

ChallengerFashion & Apparel

Value Fashion

Gap Inc.'s largest brand with $8.5B revenue; 1,200 stores offering affordable family fashion with extended sizes and BODEQUALITY pricing competing with Target and H&M.

AI VisibilityBeta
Overall Score
B60
Category Rank
#2 of 2
AI Consensus
50%
Trend
down
Per Platform
ChatGPT
63
Perplexity
53
Gemini
55

About

Old Navy is Gap Inc.'s largest and most profitable brand, offering affordable family fashion — casual clothing for women, men, kids, and babies — with a cheerful, inclusive brand personality that positions it as the value-oriented fashion destination for American families. Founded in 1994 as Gap Inc.'s value offshoot and now operating approximately 1,200 stores across the US and Canada, Old Navy generates approximately $8.5 billion in annual revenue, making it the largest specialty apparel retailer in the United States by store count and one of the few truly mass-market fashion brands.

Full profile

AI Visibility Head-to-Head

23
Overall Score
60
#841
Category Rank
#2
60
AI Consensus
50
stable
Trend
down
17
ChatGPT
63
29
Perplexity
53
31
Gemini
55
33
Claude
71
32
Grok
51

Track AI Visibility in Real Time

Monitor how your brand performs across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, and Grok daily.